Process Safety

Preliminary Hazard Analysis vs Process Hazard Analysis

Preliminary hazard analysis vs process hazard analysis — chemical process area with a jacketed reactor, vent stack and bunded storage tank | Global Formulation
A reaction vessel with its relief and vent path beside a bunded storage tank: early hazard studies look at a concept like this, and the regulated analysis examines it once drawn.

Two different studies share the abbreviation PHA, and a project team that is asked for one has to find out which is meant. A preliminary hazard analysis is an early-design review that lists a concept's hazards, makes an initial risk assessment and proposes mitigation. A process hazard analysis is the formal hazard evaluation that United States process safety rules require for a covered process. The same name is used in defence and aerospace system safety, so this guide states where that meaning ends and the process-industry meaning begins. It draws on the US Department of Defense (DoD) standard MIL-STD-882E and on Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS) guidance. The regulated meaning comes from rules of the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The approach reflects the HAZOP and HAZID studies that Global Formulation supports for plant owners.

Preliminary Hazard Analysis vs Process Hazard Analysis: Two Studies, One Abbreviation

The two names look interchangeable, and they are not. A preliminary hazard analysis belongs to early design, when only a concept exists. A process hazard analysis belongs to a defined process with drawings, and in the United States it is a legal requirement for covered processes. The table compares the two on the points that decide which one a project needs.

CriterionPreliminary hazard analysisProcess hazard analysis
Where the term is usedSystem-safety standards such as MIL-STD-882E, and the CCPS hazard evaluation guidelinesUnited States rules: OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119(e) and EPA 40 CFR 68.67
Project stageConcept and early design, before detailed drawings existDetailed design before start-up, then revalidation during operation
Question it answersWhat hazards does this concept create, and what should the design do about them?Are the hazards of this process identified, evaluated and controlled?
Typical inputsThe concept description, the materials, the energy sources, the site concept and experience from similar plantsProcess safety information, including piping and instrumentation diagrams (P&IDs), relief design basis and thermal and chemical stability data
MethodA non-scenario-based review of hazards, causes, effects and mitigation, in the CCPS classificationOne or more listed methods, such as What-If, Checklist or hazard and operability study (HAZOP), or an appropriate equivalent
Status in the US rulesNot a listed method; OSHA's non-mandatory Appendix C suggests it as an aid to prioritising which processes to analyse firstRequired for covered processes under OSHA process safety management and EPA Program 3
Typical outputA hazard register with initial risk assessment and proposed mitigationA record of the analysis, recommendations, and the documented resolution of each recommendation
Both studies are abbreviated PHA The abbreviation list of MIL-STD-882E defines PHA as Preliminary Hazard Analysis. The CCPS index uses process hazard analysis (PHA) and abbreviates the early study as PreHA. A contract that says only PHA has not said which study it wants.

Both studies are forms of hazard identification and risk assessment, the generic activity, but neither name is a synonym for it. The sections below take each study in turn, place them in a project and show how to choose between them.

Preliminary Hazard Analysis: The Early-Design Study

A preliminary hazard analysis asks what can go wrong with a design that is still a concept. It is run early because the cheapest hazard to remove is one that has not been drawn yet. The study is broad and shallow by design, since the detail it would need does not exist. Its value is to shape the design and to decide what the later, deeper studies must examine.

System-safety origin: MIL-STD-882E

In system safety the term comes from MIL-STD-882E, the US Department of Defense standard practice for system safety. Task 201 compiles a Preliminary Hazard List of the potential hazards of a concept early in development. Task 202 then performs a preliminary hazard analysis to identify hazards, assess the initial risks and identify potential mitigation measures. The standard applies when a solicitation or contract requires it, and the edition read for this guide is MIL-STD-882E with Change 1, dated 27 September 2023.

For each hazard, Task 202 requires an initial risk assessment using the standard's severity and probability definitions, unless a tailored scheme is formally approved. It also requires mitigation measures chosen by the system safety design order of precedence, which ranks them by decreasing effectiveness and starts with eliminating the hazard through design selection. The standard lists the sources of hazard to consider, including energy sources, hazardous materials, interfaces, operating environment, procedures, health hazards and human factors. Its tables and matrix are written for defense systems, so this guide does not reproduce them or apply them to a process plant.

Process-industry use: PreHA in the CCPS guidelines

The CCPS book Guidelines for Hazard Evaluation Procedures (3rd edition, 2008) lists preliminary hazard analysis as a procedure in its own right. It sits in the chapter on non-scenario-based procedures, beside safety review, relative ranking and checklist analysis. The scenario-based chapter holds What-If analysis, HAZOP, failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA), fault tree analysis and bow-tie analysis. The book also includes a worked example of a preliminary hazard analysis at conceptual design.

In a process project the study is run at conceptual design, when the process concept and the main materials are known but detailed drawings are not. The team reviews the materials and their properties, the reactions, the energy sources, the inventories, the site concept and the lessons from similar plants. These prompts echo the sources of hazard in MIL-STD-882E, translated to a chemical plant. The output is a hazard register with initial mitigation proposals and a list of items for the later studies.

A preliminary hazard analysis example: one generic row

A preliminary hazard analysis records each hazard in a short worksheet. The columns are the hazard, its cause, its effect, the controls proposed at concept stage and the follow-up. The row below is invented and generic, and it carries no risk rating. System-safety versions add an initial risk assessment from the project's own severity and probability definitions.

HazardCauseEffectControls proposed at conceptFollow-up
Flammable solvent held in an intermediate tankOverfilling, or a leak near an ignition sourceFire or release of flammable vapourReduce the inventory, and place the tank clear of ignition sources and occupied buildings, with distances taken from the applicable codeCarry forward to the detailed-design hazard study and the layout review

At detailed design the same hazard is examined again, node by node. The transfer line that fills the tank is tested against deviations such as more flow, and the safeguards actually drawn on the P&ID are recorded. That second examination is the work of the process hazard analysis.

Process Hazard Analysis: The Regulated Study

In the process industries the term process hazard analysis comes from United States regulation. The OSHA process safety management standard requires one for covered processes, and the EPA Risk Management Program (RMP) rule requires one for Program 3 processes. The requirement is for a hazard evaluation that is appropriate to the complexity of the process. It must identify, evaluate and control the hazards involved in the process.

United States, OSHA: 29 CFR 1910.119(e)

Paragraph (e) of 29 CFR 1910.119 sets the requirement for a covered process. The employer performs an initial analysis, using one or more of the listed methodologies, and revalidates it at least every five years. Before any analysis, the employer compiles process safety information under paragraph (d), including P&IDs, the relief system design and design basis, and thermal and chemical stability data. The bullets below set out what an owner can check against a report.

  • Method — paragraph (e)(2): What-If, Checklist, What-If/Checklist, Hazard and Operability Study (HAZOP), Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA), Fault Tree Analysis or an appropriate equivalent.
  • Content — paragraph (e)(3): the hazards of the process, any previous incident with potential for catastrophic consequences, the engineering and administrative controls and the consequences of their failure.
  • Further topics — paragraph (e)(3) also adds facility siting, human factors and a qualitative evaluation of the possible safety and health effects of failure of controls.
  • Team — paragraph (e)(4): expertise in engineering and process operations, at least one employee with experience specific to the process, and one member who knows the method.
  • Follow-up — paragraph (e)(5): a system to address the findings promptly, with documented resolution and a written schedule of actions.
  • Revalidation — paragraph (e)(6): an update at least every five years, by a team that meets the team requirements.
  • Records — paragraph (e)(7): the analyses, the updates and the documented resolution of recommendations are kept for the life of the process.

Paragraph (e)(1) also requires the employer to determine and document the order in which covered processes are analysed. The rationale considers the extent of the hazards, the number of potentially affected employees, the age of the process and its operating history. OSHA's non-mandatory Appendix C suggests a preliminary or gross hazard analysis as one aid to that ranking. Paragraph (c) adds that employers consult employees and their representatives on the conduct of the analyses and give them access to the results.

The standard's coverage, set out in paragraph (a), depends on the chemicals and quantities in the process. Our guide to the HAZOP study sets out the coverage test and the deliverables when HAZOP is the chosen method.

United States, EPA: 40 CFR 68.67

The EPA Risk Management Program rule has its own process hazard analysis requirement in section 68.67, which applies to Program 3 processes. Program 3 includes covered processes that are subject to the OSHA standard. The section lists the same methodologies as OSHA and states that analyses completed to comply with 29 CFR 1910.119(e) are acceptable as initial analyses. It adds topics such as natural hazards, siting with respect to public receptors and, for certain processes, safer technology analysis.

Program 2 processes carry a hazard review under section 68.50 instead. That review identifies the hazards, the opportunities for equipment malfunction or human error, the safeguards, release detection, natural hazards and siting. It is updated at least every five years. The section allows checklists developed by knowledgeable persons as a guide.

The rule is under revision. The eCFR text read on 28 October 2026 includes the 2024 amendments. EPA published a proposed revision on 24 February 2026 (91 Federal Register 8970) and accepted comments until 11 May 2026. Check the current text on the EPA RMP page before relying on any provision.

Other jurisdictions

Other jurisdictions run their own major-accident regimes. Examples are the Seveso III Directive (2012/18/EU) in the European Union and the Control of Major Accident Hazards Regulations 2015 in Great Britain. This guide names them only and does not describe their clauses. Confirm the regime that applies to the site before relying on a United States description.

Process hazard analysis detail — fixed gas detector heads and a beacon above a pump skid in a chemical process area | Global Formulation
Fixed gas detector heads above a pump skid: detection is one of the engineering controls that a process hazard analysis examines.

Where Each Study Sits in a Project: From Concept to Revalidation

The two studies are stages of one hazard-management sequence, not alternatives. An early study shapes a design that does not yet have drawings. The regulated analysis then examines the controls in the design that was drawn, and it is repeated as the plant ages. Figure 1 shows the sequence for a new process under United States rules.

Illustrative sequence of hazard studies from concept to revalidation Four numbered boxes in two rows show where hazard studies sit in a new process under United States rules. The top row runs from the concept stage, where a preliminary hazard analysis produces a hazard register and early mitigation, to detailed design, where a process hazard analysis using HAZOP, What-If or another listed method is performed. An arrow leads down to the second row, which runs right to left from the pre-startup safety review, which confirms the analysis and its actions, to operation, where the analysis is revalidated at least every five years. The figure is a generic illustration. 1 ConceptPreliminary hazard analysisHazard register and early mitigation 2 Detailed designProcess hazard analysisHAZOP, What-If or another listed method 3 Before start-upPre-startup safety reviewConfirms the analysis and its actions 4 OperationRevalidationAt least every five years (US rules) Illustrative sequence for a new process under United States rules; not a schedule for any project.
Figure 1. Illustrative sequence of hazard studies for a new process under United States rules. It is not a schedule for any project.

A preliminary study is done before the controls are designed, so it proposes controls but cannot test the ones in the final design. Paragraph (e)(3) requires the regulated analysis to address the controls and the consequences of their failure. Whether a given study satisfies a legal requirement is a question for the regulator and a qualified assessor. For a new facility, paragraph (i) requires the pre-startup safety review to confirm that a process hazard analysis has been performed and its recommendations resolved or implemented before start-up.

Chemistry data feeds both studies. OSHA's process safety information includes thermal and chemical stability data, and a reaction's heat release and decomposition behaviour are measured, not assumed. Our guides to reaction calorimetry and to adiabatic temperature rise and MTSR explain that data. Moving a route from laboratory to plant puts the process on equipment that nobody has yet operated, so scale-up support is a natural point for the early hazard review.

Which Study Do You Need? A Decision Framework

The right study follows from the stage of the project, the rule that applies and the question the owner has to answer. A contract that asks for a PHA without more detail needs a written clarification before a quotation is accepted. The table matches common situations to studies. Where a regulation applies, its own list of methods decides which methods qualify.

Your situationStudyReason
A concept or route selection, with no P&IDs yetPreliminary hazard analysis, or a hazard identification (HAZID) studyHazards can still be designed out at the cost of a drawing change
Detailed design is complete and the process is covered by OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119Process hazard analysis using a listed method, before start-upParagraph (i) asks for it before highly hazardous chemicals are introduced to a new facility
A United States process is in EPA RMP Program 3Process hazard analysis under section 68.67OSHA analyses are accepted as initial analyses, and the section adds its own topics
A United States process is in EPA RMP Program 2Hazard review under section 68.50The section sets its own list of items and a five-year update
Five years have passed since the last analysis of a covered processRevalidation by a team that meets the team requirementsParagraph (e)(6) keeps the analysis consistent with the current process
A modification, new product or higher capacity at an existing plantThe study that the site's change-control process calls forChange control decides how much of the plant to re-examine
Several covered processes need analysis and the order is unclearA preliminary or gross hazard analysis to rank themParagraph (e)(1) requires a documented priority order, and Appendix C suggests this aid
A lender, insurer or contract names a PHA without saying whichAsk in writing which study and which standardThe abbreviation fits both studies
The system is a defense or aerospace systemSystem safety under the standard the contract names, such as MIL-STD-882EThis guide covers process plants only

A staged approach pairs the two studies: a preliminary hazard analysis shapes the concept, and the regulated analysis tests the design that results. Each study answers a different question, so neither replaces the other.

What Goes Wrong: When the Wrong Hazard Study Is Bought

A hazard study goes wrong in a few recognisable ways. It is requested by an ambiguous name, run at the wrong time, run on the wrong drawings or left open. Each carries a plant consequence that appears after the money is spent. The table lists the failures and the step that prevents each one.

What goes wrongConsequenceHow to prevent it
The contract says only "PHA"Each party prices a different study, and the missing one is discovered lateName the study, the rule or standard and the deliverable in the scope document
A preliminary study is run once at concept and never revisitedDesign changes made after the concept go unexaminedCarry its findings into the detailed-design study and review again at design freeze
An early-design study is presented as the regulated analysisNo examination of the designed controls exists when the pre-startup review asks for the analysisState which requirement each study answers, and confirm it with the regulator or a qualified assessor
The regulated analysis is run on outdated P&IDsThe team studies a plant that does not exist, so real hazards go unexaminedCompile the process safety information first and freeze a verified drawing revision
Recommendations are not tracked to closureThe same findings return at revalidation, and the record fails an auditKeep a register with an owner, a date and a closure note for each action
Revalidation passes the five-year dateThe analysis no longer matches the process, and the next change builds on itRecord the due date in the report and in the site calendar
A scoring scheme built for another domain is copied acrossRatings that do not map to the owner's own criteria or to process-plant consequencesAgree the owner's criteria with a qualified facilitator before the first session
Thermal data is missing for a reactive processA runaway is named as a consequence but its speed is unknownMeasure the heat release and decomposition behaviour before the study

The first three rows are prevented by a clear brief, written before any session is held. The rest are prevented by preparation and follow-through. A study of the wrong drawing or the wrong chemistry produces confident worksheets about a plant that does not behave that way.

Commissioning the Right Hazard Study: An Owner's Checklist

An owner who briefs the study precisely gets a deliverable that can be checked against a rule. The brief is short, and each line closes a question that would otherwise surface in the middle of the project. Work through the eight items below before inviting quotations. The list applies to either study.

  1. Name the study — write preliminary hazard analysis or process hazard analysis in full, with the rule, standard or contract clause that requires it.
  2. Confirm the regime — state the jurisdiction and, in the United States, whether the process is covered by OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119 and which EPA RMP program applies.
  3. Fix the project stage — concept, detailed design, pre-startup or revalidation, and the drawing revision frozen for the study.
  4. Assemble the information — for a process hazard analysis, the process safety information; for a preliminary one, the concept description, the materials and the site concept.
  5. Choose the method — for a regulated analysis, name the method from the rule's list or an appropriate equivalent methodology.
  6. Seat the team — engineering and process operations expertise, at least one person with experience of the process and a member who knows the method. Consult employees as paragraph (c) requires.
  7. Agree the outputs — the worksheets or hazard register, the recommendations with owners and dates, and a written schedule of actions.
  8. Plan the follow-through — a closure review before start-up, retention for the life of the process and the next revalidation date.

On delivery the owner should receive the following documents:

  • a statement of which study was performed and which requirement it answers;
  • the team record with names, roles and attendance;
  • the worksheets or the hazard register;
  • the action register, with an owner, a due date and a closure status for each recommendation;
  • the study basis, including the drawing revisions and the information used;
  • the date on which the study next falls due.

To check the work, compare the drawing revisions in the report with those you issued, and confirm that the report names the study and the requirement it answers. Then sample a handful of actions at random and confirm that each has an owner, a date and a status.

Competent-assessment statement Both studies are specific to a site, a design stage and the process data behind them, including measured thermal data for the actual chemistry. Each has to be led by a qualified process safety professional, carried out by a competent team and judged against the regulatory regime that applies. This guide explains the two studies so that an owner can commission and judge them; it is not a substitute for either.
Process hazard analysis siting scene — bunded storage tanks with spacing, an access road and a pipe rack at dusk | Global Formulation
A bunded storage area with spacing between tanks and an access road: facility siting is one of the topics a process hazard analysis addresses.

Owners who need hazard studies scoped and facilitated can start from our process safety and thermal hazard assessment service. It covers HAZOP and HAZID studies, thermal hazard assessment and pre-startup safety review. Where the studies sit in a delivery schedule, see our EPC and EPCM project management service. The checklist above is the brief to bring to that conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a preliminary hazard analysis?

A preliminary hazard analysis is an early-design review that lists the hazards of a concept, makes an initial risk assessment and proposes mitigation. In MIL-STD-882E it is Task 202, performed to identify hazards, assess the initial risks and identify potential mitigation measures.

Process-industry guidance, such as the CCPS hazard evaluation guidelines, lists it as a non-scenario-based procedure.

What is a process hazard analysis?

A process hazard analysis is the hazard evaluation that OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119(e) requires for a covered process. It must be appropriate to the complexity of the process and must identify, evaluate and control the hazards involved.

The employer uses one or more listed methods, such as What-If, Checklist or HAZOP, or an appropriate equivalent.

What does PHA stand for?

PHA stands for preliminary hazard analysis in system safety and in MIL-STD-882E. In process safety it stands for process hazard analysis, the term used in the OSHA and EPA rules.

The CCPS guidelines abbreviate the early study as PreHA, so a contract that says only PHA needs the study named in full.

What is the difference between a preliminary hazard analysis and a process hazard analysis?

A preliminary hazard analysis is done at concept stage, before detailed drawings exist, to shape the design. A process hazard analysis is done on a defined process and covers the controls and the consequences of their failure.

In the United States it is a legal requirement for covered processes. The two are stages of one sequence, and each answers a different question.

Is a preliminary hazard analysis required by OSHA?

Not as such. It is not one of the methodologies listed in paragraph (e)(2) of 29 CFR 1910.119, and no paragraph requires it.

OSHA's non-mandatory Appendix C notes that a preliminary or gross hazard analysis is an aid to prioritising which covered processes are analysed first.

When is a process hazard analysis required?

In the United States, OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119 requires one for the processes it covers, and EPA 40 CFR 68.67 requires one for Program 3 processes. For a new facility the pre-startup safety review confirms that the analysis has been performed and its recommendations resolved or implemented before start-up.

Other countries have their own major-accident regimes, so confirm the one that applies to the site.

How often must a process hazard analysis be updated?

In the United States, OSHA paragraph (e)(6) and EPA section 68.67 both require the analysis to be updated and revalidated at least every five years. The updating team must meet the same requirements as the original team.

Other jurisdictions set their own intervals, so check the regime that applies.

What is the difference between PHA and HAZOP?

Process hazard analysis is the requirement, and HAZOP is one of the methods that can be used to meet it. The other methods named in the OSHA text are What-If, Checklist, What-If/Checklist, Failure Mode and Effects Analysis and Fault Tree Analysis.

A preliminary hazard analysis is an earlier study with a different purpose.

What does a preliminary hazard analysis worksheet contain?

A typical worksheet has columns for the hazard, its cause, its effect, the controls proposed and the follow-up. MIL-STD-882E adds an initial risk assessment for each hazard, using the standard's severity and probability definitions.

The worksheet records hazards at concept stage and carries them forward to the detailed-design study.

Need a Hazard Study Scoped and Facilitated?

Global Formulation supports HAZOP and HAZID studies, thermal hazard assessment and pre-startup safety review, starting from the drawings and process data your plant already has.

Discuss a Safety Assessment
AK

Absar Khan

Founder & Lead Consultant, Global Formulation

Absar Khan is a senior industrial consultant with cross-disciplinary expertise spanning chemical process engineering, reaction engineering, and industrial formulation. He founded Global Formulation to provide accessible, expert-led process development and scale-up services to manufacturers and entrepreneurs in the chemical industry. Connect with him on LinkedIn.

Message on WhatsApp